求解一道英语语法题关於倒装句和时态问题的.Seldom _________ an article that was so full of lies.A.have I read B.I have read C.had I read D.I had read答案的解释是不能说先于 was 发生,因为是先有文章后才读,而不

求解一道英语语法题关於倒装句和时态问题的.Seldom _________ an article that was so full of lies.A.have I read B.I have read C.had I read D.I had read答案的解释是不能说先于 was 发生,因为是先有文章后才读,而不
求解一道英语语法题关於倒装句和时态问题的.
Seldom _________ an article that was so full of lies.
A.have I read B.I have read C.had I read D.I had read
答案的解释是不能说先于 was 发生,因为是先有文章后才读,而不是先读后才有文章.故只能选A.但我认为应该选C.不是应该是先读了之后在发现文章充满谎言吗?还是说was是一直存在的,不在乎先后.那如果将后句改成I found that it was so full of lies,那是否答案是选C呢?

求解一道英语语法题关於倒装句和时态问题的.Seldom _________ an article that was so full of lies.A.have I read B.I have read C.had I read D.I had read答案的解释是不能说先于 was 发生,因为是先有文章后才读,而不
首先肯定,否定副词seldom放句首,句子要部分倒装,所以排除B和D.
为了简化思维,我们用正常词序来思考,是：
I have seldom read an article that was so full of lies.
还是：
I had seldom read an article that was so full of lies.
再简化一下,that从句就是一个定语.可以思考,这样单独两句话,哪一句站得住脚?
I have seldom read such a bad article.
I had seldom read such a bad article.
显然第二句没有明确的过去时间作参考,是站不住脚的.
回过头来看这个句子中的定语从句的时态,觉得用一般过去时,莫名其妙!文章写出来了,出版了,就在那儿,里面谎话连篇是个事实,应用一般现在时才对!真是搞脑子!
所以题干就应是：
I have seldom read an article that is so full of lies.
不就是考查学生的倒装句知识吗?还要考现在完成时和过去完成时的话,想好一点的句子.

其实很好理解啊，文章写在读之前，所以文章是was full of lies，而文章你是刚刚读完的，所以肯定是seldom have i read
再给你个建议，看英文不要死套语法，要着力培养语感，中学生要多读简易读本，书读的多了，做题自然就变得很轻松了