一道SAT语法题,In the past,many famous painters meticulously ground their own colors,（an attention to detail that is noteworthy.）(A) an attention to detail that is noteworthy(B) inasmuch as they showed attention to detail,it is noteworthy(C)

一道SAT语法题,In the past,many famous painters meticulously ground their own colors,（an attention to detail that is noteworthy.）(A) an attention to detail that is noteworthy(B) inasmuch as they showed attention to detail,it is noteworthy(C)
一道SAT语法题,
In the past,many famous painters meticulously ground their own colors,（an attention to detail that is noteworthy.）
(A) an attention to detail that is noteworthy
(B) inasmuch as they showed attention to detail,it is noteworthy
(C) this makes it noteworthy in showing their attention to detail
(D) an idea that is noteworthy in showing their attention to detail
(E) which is noteworthy and it shows an attention to detail
请问E哪里错了?

一道SAT语法题,In the past,many famous painters meticulously ground their own colors,（an attention to detail that is noteworthy.）(A) an attention to detail that is noteworthy(B) inasmuch as they showed attention to detail,it is noteworthy(C)
在英语语法当中,代词(it/this/that/which) 只能指代前文出现过的名词,而不能指代 句子或者动作.
比如,Hans doesn't have breakfast everyday; this/that/it will harm his health.
或者 Hans doesn't have breakfast everyday,which will harm his health.
都是错的,(which这句话在我们高考语法中,是正确的,有特殊用法可以指代前面整句话的内容,但是SAT里 是错的,因为which为关系代词,是个代词,就不能指代一句话).
只有一种情况,一个词可以概括或者指代一句话,那就是 用同位语.还是上面那句话,下面这种说法就是对的:
Hans doesn't have breakfast everyday,a habit which will harm his health.
由"a habit"同位语 概括前面这句话,然后which引导定语从句再修饰这个同位语名词.
在这句话中,就是同样的原因.E选项which不能指代前面整句话,在语法上which只能修饰紧跟的名词 colors,与原句义就不符了,而且 后面的it更加的指代不清,简单的 判断 整句话都没有可数名词单数 可以被这个it指代.
原本的意思是 "过去,许多著名的画家都小心翼翼的抛光他们的颜色,(这是) 一种 引人注目的 对细节的关注."

and 连接错误，前面是which,后面是it。这两个不能连接，因为前面是从句，而后面是主句。

这是一个同位语结构，在一个完整的句子后面，往往用一个抽象名词来概括逗号前面句子的内容，然后再用一个分句或结构对该抽象名词进行进一步修饰说明。这样，这个抽象名词和前面的整个句子（有时是句子的某一个重要成分）构成了一种同位关系。
在SAT考试中，看到这一类同位结构的选项，一般可以认定是正确选项。
例：I failed my exam and lost my girlfriend, a ...

全部展开

这是一个同位语结构，在一个完整的句子后面，往往用一个抽象名词来概括逗号前面句子的内容，然后再用一个分句或结构对该抽象名词进行进一步修饰说明。这样，这个抽象名词和前面的整个句子（有时是句子的某一个重要成分）构成了一种同位关系。
在SAT考试中，看到这一类同位结构的选项，一般可以认定是正确选项。
例：I failed my exam and lost my girlfriend, a situation that I had never encountered in before.
在上句中，用a situation对I failed my exam and lost my girlfriend进行概述，在situation后用一个从句对它进行进一步修饰，从而使situation和前面的完整句子构成一种特殊的同位结构。

收起

简单呀，帮你一把~！
【分析】
知道“可逆反应”“充分非必要”吗？
这里情况一样，前者可以退出后者的noteworthy，但是反之，noteworthy不能得出attention to detai这个原因。
原因得到结果，但是结果是多种原因，所以E错误。、
O(∩_∩)O哈哈~，采纳吧~！...

全部展开

简单呀，帮你一把~！
【分析】
知道“可逆反应”“充分非必要”吗？
这里情况一样，前者可以退出后者的noteworthy，但是反之，noteworthy不能得出attention to detai这个原因。
原因得到结果，但是结果是多种原因，所以E错误。、
O(∩_∩)O哈哈~，采纳吧~！

收起