问一个非谓语动词的题After succeeding in landing on George Island,the captain sent a radio message to his headquarters.这句话前面succeeding是非谓语动词 我想知道这个为什么不能用过去分词 因为过去分词表完成

问一个非谓语动词的题After succeeding in landing on George Island,the captain sent a radio message to his headquarters.这句话前面succeeding是非谓语动词 我想知道这个为什么不能用过去分词 因为过去分词表完成
问一个非谓语动词的题
After succeeding in landing on George Island,the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
这句话前面succeeding是非谓语动词 我想知道这个为什么不能用过去分词 因为过去分词表完成啊 这个是已经完成的啊
Succeeded in landing on George Island,the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
Having succeeded in landing on George Island,the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
这两个句子对么？能表示上述句子么，有什么区别？

问一个非谓语动词的题After succeeding in landing on George Island,the captain sent a radio message to his headquarters.这句话前面succeeding是非谓语动词 我想知道这个为什么不能用过去分词 因为过去分词表完成
the captian succeeded in ...是主动语态 用ing形式
Job finished,I leave for home.这样可以表示被动,完成
非要用完成时态的话此句改成After having succeeded in...

鄙人浅见：这个似乎涉及到了英语语感的问题。一般情况下after后接动词短语构成时间状语，都是跟现在进行时的动词，不用考虑到动词的时间变化。

@After succeeding in landing on George Island, the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
先说明一下，这里用 succeeding，是因为after是介词，介词后面跟ing形式，呵呵，你粗心了哦
@Succeeded in landing on George I...

全部展开

@After succeeding in landing on George Island, the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
先说明一下，这里用 succeeding，是因为after是介词，介词后面跟ing形式，呵呵，你粗心了哦
@Succeeded in landing on George Island, the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
Having succeeded in landing on George Island, the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
这两个句子对么？能表示上述句子么，有什么区别？
这句子是对的。

收起

Succeeded in landing on George Island, the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
是错误的，因为Succeeded分词作状语应表被动，但是Succeed不及物，没有被动语态，直接就是错误。
Having succeeded in landing on George Is...

全部展开

Succeeded in landing on George Island, the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
是错误的，因为Succeeded分词作状语应表被动，但是Succeed不及物，没有被动语态，直接就是错误。
Having succeeded in landing on George Island, the captain sent a radio
message to his headquarters.
是对的，两个句子的区别是这个是现在分词(have succeeded变成现在分词)作状语，表主动，而又由于没有介词【有的话，直接prep+doing】表现后性，succeed加上了完成时【和在一起可以看做作状语的现在分词的完成时...】，成为have succeeded，再变成现在分词表主动，就是Having succeeded

收起

此句中succeeding表示主动。虽然succeeded表示完成，但不表示主动。Having succeeded in landing on George island也可以。 不过楼上的第三个答案After having succeeded....显然是错误的。after已表示完成，再用having done 的形式没有必要。