关于非谓语的一道选择题I grew up ___ to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.A.listening B.with listening C.to listen D.to have listened我觉得应该在AB当中 加不加with有什么区别吗

关于非谓语的一道选择题I grew up ___ to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.A.listening B.with listening C.to listen D.to have listened我觉得应该在AB当中 加不加with有什么区别吗
关于非谓语的一道选择题
I grew up ___ to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.
A.listening B.with listening C.to listen D.to have listened
我觉得应该在AB当中 加不加with有什么区别吗

关于非谓语的一道选择题I grew up ___ to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.A.listening B.with listening C.to listen D.to have listened我觉得应该在AB当中 加不加with有什么区别吗
英语中V-ing形式作伴随状语时,它表示的是一个次要的动作,来对谓语表示的动作加以说明或作为陪衬.一般将其置于句后,可用逗号与主句成分分开.
伴随状语顾名思义,在句子中应该是一个独立的成分(从句做状语),与主句的谓语动词相比,它具有同时性,但是意义地位较为次要,所以成为"伴随"成分.
1-在句子中应该是一个独立的成分,从句做状语
2-与谓语动词相比,伴随状语的意义居于次要地位
3-伴随状语中的动词现在分词与谓语动词同时发生
4-伴随.状语中动词的主语,与主句中谓语动词的主语相同
with+宾语+现在分词：指动作正在进行或在当时看来已是一种在持续的状态.
从你给的句中,grew up与listen to music并不是一种在持续的状态的联系,而是种伴随结构.你可以缩写：I grew up（ listening to the most fashionably mixed types of music ）in such a family of music lovers.这是个完整结构.
如果是I grew up (with listening to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.)从句中 （I was） listening to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.与I grew up并无持续的联系

I grew up ___ to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.
A.listening B.with listening C.to listen D.to have listened
我觉得应该在AB当中 加不加with有什么区别吗
答：A

全部展开

I grew up ___ to the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.
A.listening B.with listening C.to listen D.to have listened
我觉得应该在AB当中 加不加with有什么区别吗
答：A
译：我是听着。。。长大的。
析：listening ...现在分词短语作状事，表示伴随情况。
grow up with ....和。。。一起长大。这里不妥。

收起

这当然有区别的啦，任何东西都有语法限制的
像这里你不可能无缘无故在后面几个句子吧，这里是需要有连接词的，这里就是with做连接词，表示伴随的意思，我是听着。。。歌长大的

A
grew up就已经结束了 listening to是伴随状语 不用with 了 一般的with sb 或sth 的do done doing表伴随状语 这俩一般不能混在一块用吧

选A，要是用with的话，该是：I grew up _with__ the most fashionably mixed types of music in such a family of music lovers.