he ___for three years.A has joined the army B has been in the army 为什么选B

来源:学生作业帮助网 编辑:六六作业网 时间:2024/12/25 04:08:47
he___forthreeyears.AhasjoinedthearmyBhasbeeninthearmy为什么选Bhe___forthreeyears.AhasjoinedthearmyBhasbe

he ___for three years.A has joined the army B has been in the army 为什么选B
he ___for three years.A has joined the army B has been in the army 为什么选B

he ___for three years.A has joined the army B has been in the army 为什么选B
因为join是一个短暂的动作,填完表,到军队上报过道,就算是入伍了.
而be in the army则是持续性动作,所以在现在完成时里,选B has been in the army

B has been in the army

因为join不是持续性动作,不能使用现在完成时。

join 短暂性动词 短暂性动词用于完成时时不与for+一段时间连用故改为 be in

因为join是强调动作,B选项强调的是他从军三年的状态。

因为句子后面有时间段 在现在完成时中 如果有for加时间段和since加时间点 那么就要求动词必须是延续性动词 就比如说这道题 join不是延续性的 所以就要用be 明白了么?