修改病句Who are they They are doctors 哪错了?
来源：学生作业帮助网 编辑：六六作业网 时间：2024/11/08 02:52:23
修改病句Who are they They are doctors 哪错了?
修改病句Who are they They are doctors 哪错了?
修改病句Who are they They are doctors 哪错了?
从一问一答可以看出,前句是对职业的提问.对职业提问一般不用who,可用what are they?或者what do they do?或者是what are their jobs?
Who are they 意为他们是谁,他们都有谁等等,也可以表示询问职业,但很少用.通常回答是如:（they are Jack,Tom and Jim）、（they are teachers of our Middle school）.之类.
问职业要用这么说:你们是做什么的? 而不能说:你们是谁?
what do they do?
they are doctor
What are they？
They are doctor.
学英语不是要按汉语的思维进行翻译的，要知道英语的习惯，学会地道的英语。What do they do?Or What are they?
本句式问职业的所以Who are they 不对用 what do they do ?
What are they? What do they do?
They are doctors.
以答句来看，如果问的是职业就不该用who提问……
本题实际可以有两种理解
第一种是问职业，从汉语角度来说是: 他们是做什么的? 回答是：他们是医生
What do they do?或者What are they?
They are doctors.
第二种理解是问话人不知道那些人是谁或者是想知道那些人是谁，此时可以用who来提问，但回答时一般要比较确切些（说出名字或者限定是哪里的人）。此种场景下可以这样来说：
全部展开
本题实际可以有两种理解
第一种是问职业，从汉语角度来说是: 他们是做什么的? 回答是：他们是医生
What do they do?或者What are they?
They are doctors.
第二种理解是问话人不知道那些人是谁或者是想知道那些人是谁，此时可以用who来提问，但回答时一般要比较确切些（说出名字或者限定是哪里的人）。此种场景下可以这样来说：
Who are they?
They are Mike, Tom and Nancy, the doctors from No.1 Hospital.
收起
问职业用what不用who